CASE FILE
TCU-612

The Wrong Target Again and Again – How a Murder-for-Hire Went So Wrong

VERIFIED SOURCES 259 PRIMARY DOCUMENTS
Homicide Murder for Hire
CASE FILE INVESTIGATED

LISTEN TO THE FULL INVESTIGATION

0:00 / 0:00
Player not working? Listen on
Subscribe on Substack

LISTEN & SUBSCRIBE

Available on all major podcast platforms

Case Narrative

Complete written investigation summary

The Wrong Target: Inside Mobile’s Murder-for-Hire Conspiracy That Killed Everyone But Its Intended Victim

John Fitzgerald McCarroll Jr. orchestrated one of the most catastrophically failed murder-for-hire conspiracies in Alabama history. Between September and December 2022, the 30-year-old Mobile resident hired multiple shooters, provided illegal machineguns, and directed attacks across two states in an attempt to kill Milton Carter. The result: two innocent people murdered, one woman permanently paralyzed, six others wounded—and Milton Carter walked away without a scratch. On April 2, 2025, U.S. District Judge Terry F. Moorer sentenced McCarroll to mandatory life in federal prison. His co-defendants Darrius Dwayne Rowser, 21, and Lyteria Isheeia Hollis, 31, received the same sentence.

How the McCarroll Murder-for-Hire Conspiracy Operated

The conspiracy began as a revenge plot. According to federal prosecutors, McCarroll blamed Milton Carter for the October 19, 2020 death of Ryan Campbell, a man described as “like a little brother” to McCarroll. There was one problem with this theory: Mobile Police arrested Barron Morris for Campbell’s murder, and on August 14, 2023, Morris pleaded guilty to intentionally killing Campbell during a robbery—not a targeted hit. Milton Carter was never charged with any involvement in Campbell’s death.

McCarroll blamed Carter anyway. Prosecutors characterized what followed as “a relentless campaign of revenge” that created “a bloody trail of collateral damage across Alabama and Mississippi.”

The conspiracy operated through a network of shooters and facilitators. McCarroll recruited Reginald Fluker as the first hitman. He directed his girlfriend, Lyteria Hollis, to facilitate Cash App payments to shooters before and after attacks. He provided weapons, including illegally modified machineguns. And when one attempt failed, he simply tried again—with catastrophic results for innocent people.

Bank Nightlife: The First Victim (September 18, 2022)

At approximately 2:30 a.m. on September 18, 2022, McCarroll and Reginald Fluker were inside Bank Nightlife club at 271 Azalea Road in Mobile. According to trial testimony, McCarroll handed Fluker a gun inside the crowded club and physically pointed out his target: Milton Carter.

Fluker opened fire. Five shots. But he hit the wrong man.

Derrick “Day Day” Shavers, 31, a Walmart team lead and single father of a six-year-old son, was shot four times. He was rushed to USA Hospital in critical condition. His family kept vigil for three weeks. On October 8, 2022, Shavers died from his injuries.

His sister Siera Gray later told reporters: “He was a hard-working man, very kind to people. He didn’t meet any strangers.” His son’s “whole world revolved around” his father.

Milton Carter walked out of that club unharmed.

The Mississippi Murder: Nicholaus Craig (September 21, 2022)

Three days after the Bank Nightlife shooting, McCarroll’s conspiracy expanded across state lines. He directed 19-year-old Darrius Rowser and accomplice Karmelo Cortez Morris Derks to travel to D’Iberville, Mississippi to steal vehicles for surveillance operations back in Mobile.

Around 2:00 a.m. at the Scarlet Pearl Casino Resort parking lot, Rowser approached a Dodge Charger. Inside was Nicholaus Craig, 36, a Best Buy manager from California who was originally from Mobile. Craig had flown to New Orleans with his girlfriend to celebrate his birthday—September 20 had been his 36th birthday. He was heading to Mobile to visit his mother.

Craig’s girlfriend, Iman Drummond, was on the phone with him when she heard: “Get the [expletive] out of the car.” Then the line went dead. She called back six times. No answer.

Rowser shot Craig through the car window. When Derks later asked why, Rowser reportedly said: “It had to be done.” He later admitted he “may have got the wrong person.”

Craig’s mother, Sumorris Tucker, described her son as “tall, handsome, respectable—a good son” who pursued creative interests in art, photography, and his own clothing business.

Paparazzi Lounge: One Woman Paralyzed (November 26, 2022)

Undeterred by two deaths, McCarroll escalated. On November 26, 2022, at approximately 2:16 a.m., he provided Darrius Rowser with an illegally modified machinegun and sent him to Paparazzi Lounge at 216 Dauphin Street during a high school reunion afterparty.

Rowser opened fire at Milton Carter. He hit four wrong people instead. A 27-year-old woman was shot in the neck. She survived but was left permanently paralyzed. Three others suffered non-life-threatening wounds.

Milton Carter walked away unharmed—again.

Judge Moorer later noted the paralyzed victim’s “remarkable resilience” at sentencing.

The Walmart Shooting and Digital Evidence (December 27, 2022)

On December 27, 2022, at 8:35 p.m., Rowser, Tysean “JP” Pierce, and Derks were inside a Walmart Supercenter at 101 East I-65 Service Road South. They were shopping for GPS tracking devices—hoping to finally locate Milton Carter. In the self-checkout area, an altercation erupted. Rowser and Pierce opened fire with illegal machineguns, wounding two shoppers.

But the most damaging evidence came from Rowser himself. After the Paparazzi shooting, he created Instagram voice messages bragging to co-conspirators: “Bro! I just… shot four folks in the club with—with three bullets!” Prosecutors described Rowser’s “social media content” as “replete with significant evidence.”

McCarroll continued his criminal conduct even after his September 27, 2023 arrest. From Mobile County Metro Jail, he directed Hollis via recorded phone calls to hide the murder weapon from the Bank Nightlife shooting at her residence. He arranged for Fluker to sign a false affidavit claiming McCarroll wasn’t involved—despite the recorded warning that plays on every jail call: “This call is being recorded and monitored.”

Arrest, Prosecution, and Sentencing

Federal agents arrested John Fitzgerald McCarroll Jr. in Mobile on September 27, 2023. The case was prosecuted by Assistant U.S. Attorneys Justin Roller and S. Gaillard Ladd Jr. in United States District Court for the Southern District of Alabama, Case No. 1:23-cr-00169, before Judge Terry F. Moorer.

The three-week trial in October 2024 featured Instagram voice messages, financial records showing Hollis’s Cash App payments to shooters, cooperating witness testimony from Reginald Fluker and others, and jail phone recordings of McCarroll directing obstruction. On October 25, 2024, the jury returned guilty verdicts on all counts for McCarroll, Rowser, and Hollis.

On April 2, 2025, Judge Moorer imposed sentences:

John Fitzgerald McCarroll Jr.: Life in federal prison

Darrius Dwayne Rowser: Life in federal prison (despite being 19-21 during the crimes)

Lyteria Isheeia Hollis: Life in federal prison

Reginald Fluker: 30 years (reduced for substantial cooperation)

Karmelo Derks: 84 months (7 years) for cooperation

The court ordered $1,243,397.72 in restitution to victims. In the federal system, life means life—no parole.

Legacy of the McCarroll Case

The McCarroll conspiracy stands as a stark example of how murder-for-hire plots endanger innocent people far beyond their intended targets. Nine victims paid the price for McCarroll’s obsessive pursuit of a man who—according to the justice system that convicted someone else—had nothing to do with Ryan Campbell’s death.

The case also demonstrates how modern criminals become their own prosecutors. Rowser’s Instagram bragging, Hollis’s Cash App records, and McCarroll’s recorded jail calls created an evidence trail that no defense could overcome.

Prosecutor S. Gaillard Ladd Jr. characterized it as “a street war, a blood feud” that resulted in “death and violence” across two states. For the families of Derrick Shavers and Nicholaus Craig, for the woman who will never walk again, the question remains: How many lives were destroyed because one man was absolutely certain about something that wasn’t true?

Milton Carter, the one person marked for death, survived everything. The defendants who tried to kill him will die in prison.

Primary Court Documents

Verifiable case records used in this investigation

Judgment
Case No. 1:23-CR-00169-001

Judgment in a Criminal Case - United States v. John Fitzgerald McCarroll, Jr.

Docket Date April 22, 2025
Doc # 646
Verify on PACER
Indictment
Case No. 1:23-CR-00169-TFM-MU

Indictment - United States v. John McCarroll et al.

Docket Date August 24, 2023
Doc # 1
Verify on PACER
Court Order
Case No. 1:23-CR-00169

DOJ Press Release - Defendants Sentenced to Life in Prison for Deadly Murder-for-Hire Conspiracy

Docket Date April 2, 2025
Verify on PACER

Full Episode Transcript

Complete verbatim text • Searchable • Accessible

[0:06] It's September 18th, 2022, at the Bank Nightlife in Mobile, Alabama. 2.30 in the morning. [0:15] The late summer heat is still hanging in the air. It's one of those warm southern nights where nobody wanted to go home. The club is packed. I mean, packed! People streaming out after a concert. Music still pounding through speakers. Conversations and laughter mixing with bass you know it's that saturday night energy, inside john mccarroll finds his friend reginald fluker he hands him something a gun, right there in the crowd and then mccarroll does something that will haunt this case he physically points. That one, Milton Carter, that's the target. [1:11] Five shots, people scattered, ducking, running for exit, someone's down. Blood is pooling on the floor. But when the chaos settles, Milton Carter walks out of the club Alive The man bleeding 31-year-old Derek Shavers Father of a 6-year-old A Walmart team lead Wrong place Wrong time Wrong person, And that's just the beginning. [1:49] This is the story of what happens when revenge targets the wrong person. Again. And again. And again. When social media turns criminals into their own prosecutors. And when nine innocent people pay the price for someone else's war. And when the one person marked for death survives everything. [2:23] I'm Steve Rode. Welcome to True Crime Cases You Haven't Heard. Before we go any further, let me tell you exactly where this story comes from. Everything you're about to hear, the nightclub shooting, the Mississippi murder, the machine gun attack, the Walmart shooting, all of it, it all comes directly from federal court documents, FBI evidence, trial testimony, jury verdicts, and verified news coverage. Look, I don't deal in rumors. I don't deal in speculation. And when I tell you something happened in this episode, it's because prosecutors presented it to a jury. And that jury rendered a verdict. Some defendants have pending appeals. Milton Carter was never charged with any crime discussed here. But the events I'm describing, they're anchored to the record. Now let me tell you what that record revealed. [3:31] For 30 years, I've been investigating criminals, financial fraudsters, con artists, people who hurt others for profit. I've seen a lot of stupid criminal decisions. But what you're about to hear might be the most spectacular failure I've ever encountered. [3:51] Between September and December 2022, John McCarroll orchestrated a murder-for-hire conspiracy in Mobile, Alabama. He hired multiple shooters, provided illegal weapons, including machine guns. He directed attack after attack after attack. His target was Milton Carter. And here's what happened. Two innocent people murdered. One person permanently paralyzed. Six more wounded. Months of terror across Alabama and Mississippi. And Milton Carter? He never got a scratch. But the most damning part? The defendants documented their own crimes. Instagram voice messages bragging about shootings. Facebook posts mocking failed murder attempts. Even continuing to obstruct justice from jail on recorded phone lines. To understand how this conspiracy went so catastrophically wrong We need to start with the spark The death that set everything in motion. [5:14] October 19th, 2020. Mobile, Alabama. A young man named Ryan Campbell is killed. He was like a little brother to John McCarroll. The two were close, and when Campbell died, McCarroll was devastated. Mobile police investigated. They made an arrest. A man named Baron Morris was charged with the murder. In August 2023, Morris pleaded guilty to intentionally murdering Ryan Campbell. He was sentenced to 20 years in Alabama's state penitentiary. [5:53] But here's the critical detail that changes everything. Ryan Campbell wasn't killed in some targeted hit. He was killed during a robbery. A robbery committed by Baron Morris. It was random violence. Wrong place, wrong time. The kind of senseless street crime that happens in cities across America. And the system worked. Police identified the killer. Prosecutors secured a conviction. And justice served. But John McCarroll didn't accept it. Police arrested and convicted Baron Morris for Campbell's murder. Morris was even prepared to testify that Milton Carter had nothing to do with Ryan Campbell's death. It was just a robbery gone bad. But McCarroll blamed Carter anyway. His grief transformed into what prosecutors would later call a relentless campaign of revenge. [7:04] Now picture John McCarroll in late 2020, 2021, and 2022. Living immobile. Known on the streets as Juvie. A nickname from his youth. His records showed misdemeanor convictions, drug paraphernalia, no pistol permit, reckless endangerment, and one conviction even granted him youthful offender status. But no felonies and nothing violent. Until Ryan Campbell died, and then everything changed. McCarroll became fixated on one goal, kill Milton Carter. He began recruiting Reginald Fluker, a friend, Darius Rouser, 19 years old, and eventually Jimmery Spears. He brought his girlfriend, Leteria Hollis, into the conspiracy, to facilitate payments and logistics. And McCarroll provided weapons, directed surveillance, spent months planning and coordinating, preparing, despite evidence that Baron Morris, not Carter, committed the robbery that killed Campbell. By September 2022, McCarroll was ready. [8:32] September 18th, a packed nightclub. And a pointing finger about to steal the wrong man's fate. [8:44] It's Saturday night. Bank Nightlife on Azalea Road. A concert just ended. The club's packed with people having a good time. Among them, Milton Carter. And among them, John McCarroll and Reginald Fluker. And this is where everything goes wrong. Picture it. It's 2.30 in the morning. The concert's over. But the crowd's still thick. People laughing and talking. You know, that Saturday night energy when nobody wants the evening to end? [9:16] John McCarroll isn't there to party. He's there with a plan. McCarroll hands Fluker a gun right there in the crowd. And then McCarroll does something multiple witnesses would later describe. He physically points. He points at a man he believes is Milton Carter. That one, right there. Fluka raises the gun. Five rounds fire into the crowd. People scatter, some dropping to the floor. Others are running for the exits. In the confusion, someone goes down. Blood is slowly spreading across the nightclub floor. Security rushes in they find a man shot multiple times critical condition he's rushed to the hospital milton carter he walked out of that club not a scratch the shooter fired five rounds in his direction and somehow missed him completely. [10:23] The man on the floor fighting for his life? Derek Shavers. 31 years old, father of a 6-year-old son. Worked as a team lead at Walmart for 5 years. He was just there enjoying the concert. Wrong place, wrong time, wrong person. Derek Shavers underwent emergency surgery. He was shot 4 times. His family rushed to his bedside and his aunt told reporters, My nephew is a single parent. He decided to go out and have fun with his friends. That's it. His sister would later describe him as a hard-working man who was very kind to people and didn't meet any strangers. A father, a Walmart team lead, and a man who just wanted a night out with friends. And now all of that hung in the balance as Shavers lay in a hospital bed. [11:28] Mobile police responded. Witnesses gave statements. Surveillance footage was collected. And the investigation was just beginning. Arrests wouldn't come for months. Which meant McCarroll was still free, still planning, and still directing. [11:48] Just three days later, while Shavers fought for his life and detectives worked to identify suspects, the conspiracy would claim another victim 300 miles away in a Mississippi casino parking lot. [12:06] September 21st, 2022, three days after bank nightlife, the unseasonably warm September weather continues across the Gulf Coast. And while Derek Shavers fights for his life in a mobile hospital, two young men drive north to Mississippi. John McCarroll had directed Darius Rauser and another man, Carmelo Cortez Morris Dirks, to steal a car. They needed an untraceable vehicle for surveillance back in Mobile. They wanted to track Milton Carter's movements. And they ended up at the Scarlet Pearl Casino Resort in DeIverville, Mississippi. be. Around two in the morning, Rouser and Dirks positioned their already stolen Nissan Altima near a Dodge Charger in the parking lot. Rouser told Dirks, I'll do the rest. And then Rouser approached the Charger. Inside that Charger, 36-year-old Nicholas Craig. [13:19] Craig was a Best Buy manager who'd moved to California in 2019. Originally from Mobile, his mother, Sue Morris Tucker, would later describe him as tall, handsome, respectable, a good son. He pursued creative endeavors, college for art, amateur photography, and even his own clothing business. September 20th, the day before, had been Nick's 36th birthday. He'd flown to New Orleans with his girlfriend to celebrate. And they were staying at the Scarlet Pearl and then heading to Mobile so Nick could visit his mother and continue the birthday celebrations. But Nick had been experiencing back pain from recent surgery. And around 2 in the morning, he went to his vehicle, probably to sit in the car and get some relief. His girlfriend iman drummond was on the phone with him she was having a normal conversation with nick and then something shifted she heard nick's voice change and then get the fuck out of the car the line went dead she called back six times no answer. [14:41] Darius Rouser shot Nicholas Craig through the car window. A single gunshot. Nick Craig died in that parking lot. And here's the bitter irony. They shot him, but didn't even successfully steal the car. Craig's body was found inside his rented Dodge Charger. Another botched operation in a conspiracy built on failures. And later, when Dirks asked why he shot the man, Rouser reportedly said, it had to be done. They needed a car, any car. Nick Craig happened to be in the wrong vehicle, in the wrong parking lot, at the wrong time. Iman Drummond's 911 call was later played for the jury, the recording of her frantically trying to explain what she'd heard over the phone. After the shooting, Rouser and Dirks drove their stolen Nissan back to Alabama to Azalea Apartments in Pritchard and then set it on fire, trying to destroy evidence. Nick Cage came home to visit his mother for his birthday, and he never made it. Wrong person, wrong victim. And Milton Carter? Still alive. [16:08] Three weeks later, Derek Shavers' family would stop praying for recovery And they'd start planning a funeral, Three weeks after bank nightlife Derek Shavers never recovered October 8, 2022, a Saturday After approximately three weeks fighting for his life Derek Day-Day Shavers Died. [16:38] A candlelight vigil was held on October 13th. Family and friends gathered, and they spelled out Long Live Day on the concrete. His sister, Sierra Gray, told reporters, We tried to cope with it the best way we can, but it's hard for all of us. His mom, our dad, our sisters, and she described her brother as a hard-working man who was very kind to people and didn't meet any strangers. Derek left behind a six-year-old son whose whole world revolved around his father. The hardworking man, the kind soul who didn't meet any strangers, the father whose six-year-old's world revolved around him. All of it ended because Reginald Fluker shot the wrong person. It was the first confirmed death in Mobile. The second body over all. And John McCarroll, he's still free, still directing, still not finished. [17:45] Thanksgiving weekend was coming, and with it, the next attack. [17:52] It's November 26, 2022, Thanksgiving weekend. Downtown Mobile, on Dauphin Street, in the Entertainment District, it's unseasonably warm for late November. the kind of warmth that kept people out late on a Saturday night. McCarroll is still free. Police are still investigating the bank nightlife shooting. And he's not finished. [18:20] McCarroll contacted Darius Rouser, provided him with an illegally modified machine gun, and directed him to find Milton Carter and complete the job. Rouser was now 20 years old. He'd already killed Nicholas Craig in Mississippi. Though that connection wasn't publicly known. And McCarroll gave Rouser specific instructions, surveillance, weapons, and timing. Thanksgiving weekend, a high school reunion after party. The paparazzi lounge was packed. And one woman had been there only about 25 minutes. Around 2.16 in the morning, Darius Rauser opened fire with the machine gun. The scene was just devastation. Four people were shot, and Milton Carter, once again, unharmed somehow. [19:23] Police found two 27-year-old victims at the scene, one male and one female. The female suffered life-threatening injuries. She was shot in the neck, and the bullet caused permanent paralysis. Two more victims arrived at the hospital via personal vehicles with multiple gunshot wounds. Non-life-threatening, but injuries nonetheless. The 27-year-old woman shot in the neck would never walk again. She went from walking into downtown Mobile to spend the rest of her life in a wheelchair. She had just been out with friends. It was Thanksgiving weekend. A high school reunion and in the wrong place when someone else's war came through. [20:15] One victim, Michaelia Tillman, would eventually speak publicly. I heard gunshots as I was turning around to run. My body went into total shock, and I fell to the ground instantly. Three separate incidents now. Two confirmed deaths. One permanent paralysis and multiple wounded. Bank nightlife, one dead. Mississippi, one dead. Paparazzi lounge, one paralyzed. Three wounded. and the target still walking around. [20:55] Mobile police started seeing a pattern. McCarroll's name kept appearing. The bank nightlife shooting, now paparazzi. [21:04] Shell casings matched. Witnesses overlapped. Surveillance video showed a man in a hoodie. That was rousal. A quick aside here. You know, this one's personal for me as a longtime viewer of the first 48 TV series. Leading the Mobile investigation was Detective Jermaine Rogers, a homicide detective, who appeared on the A&E series from 2017 to 2022. And if you've watched the show, you know what that means. These aren't theoretical investigators. They're detectives working real cases in real time, with cameras documenting every decision. At a January 2023 bond hearing, Rogers presented the evidence that connected these shootings. Surveillance footage, cell phone records, and witness statements. The kind of methodical police work the show is known for. Now, I spent two years as a police dispatcher, so I've seen how detectives operate under pressure, and Rogers was building a federal conspiracy case across multiple jurisdictions while victims were still being shot. That's the reality behind the TV show and why this investigation mattered to me. [22:31] Investigators realized they weren't dealing with random violence. They were dealing with a coordinated campaign, and it was escalating. But McCarroll wasn't deterred by catastrophic failures. He wasn't deterred by the fact that every attempt was hitting the wrong person. He kept going. Two days after Christmas, a Walmart. The shopping trip that would finally crack the whole conspiracy wide open. It's now December 27th, 2022, two days after Christmas. The Arctic cold that had gripped Mobile over the holiday weekend was finally breaking. [23:13] Temperatures recovering from the frigid Christmas that had brought record lows to the Gulf Coast. Walmart Supercenter on East Interstate 65 Service Road in Mobile. Prime shopping hours, 8.35 in the evening. [23:30] Rouser, Tyshawn J.P. Pierce, and Carmelo Dirks were at the store. Their purpose? Shopping for a GPS tracking device. To finally locate Milton Carter and finish the job. In the self-checkout area, an altercation erupted. Rouser and Pierce opened fire with illegally modified machine guns. Two shoppers were shot, a man and a woman. Both suffered non-life-threatening injuries. Both were traumatized. And customers and employees fled. The store locked down. When FBI agents eventually executed search warrants on the defendants' phones and social media accounts, they found something extraordinary. The conspiracy wasn't hidden. It was documented. It was bragged about. And it was posted publicly. Instagram voice messages between conspirators discussed the shooting, not in code and not carefully, just openly. Rousers sent voice messages bragging about attempts on Milton Carter's life. [24:48] FBI agents testified about one Instagram voice message, Rouser, two days after paparazzi, saying, Bro, I just shot four folks in the club with three bullets. The voice messages had been compressed. They were muffled quality, the kind of audio you get when someone records late at night in a car or a bathroom. They were trying to keep their voice down, but they could still be heard. That tanny echo that Instagram voice messages get, not professional recordings, just casual confessions preserved forever in a phone's memory and on a server. Facebook messages discussed plans. Rouser messaged about obtaining black spray paint before the Mississippi carjacking. And the day after Craig's death, he messaged a co-defendant asking to trade guns because his was hot. [25:52] A Google search on Rouser's phone, abandoned at the Walmart, showed he'd searched for a magnetic GPS tracking device. Public posts visible to friends, visible to investigators, and visible to a jury. But the most damning evidence wasn't just the social media. It was the jailhouse phone calls. You see, after his arrest in early 2023, John McCarroll was held in Mobile County Metro Jail. Every phone call is recorded. Every conversation is logged. It's standard procedure. And there's a recording at the beginning of every call. This call is being recorded and monitored. [26:43] Even from custody, McCarroll continued working the conspiracy, coordinating with co-defendants, discussing the case, attempting to obstruct justice. He directed Hollis to hide the murder weapon from Bank Nightlife. He tried to get Fluker to sign a false affidavit claiming McCarroll wasn't involved. Recorded. Logged. Time-stamped. Admissible in court. The defendants knew this. The warning plays on every call. But they kept talking anyway. Nine victims, two dead, one paralyzed, and the evidence to prove it all? The defendants created it themselves. By the end of December 2022, the toll was devastating. [27:44] One person permanently paralyzed, six additional people wounded, nine victims total, and the intended target, Milton Carter, never got a scratch. Arrests came in waves throughout late 2022 and into 2023. Carmelo Dirks arrested December 30th, days after the Walmart shooting. Darius Rouser, arrested shortly after, charged with attempted murder, assault connected to paparazzi, and the Mississippi murder. John Fitzgerald McCarroll Jr., he was already locked up on state charges. Federal charges were added after the FBI connected the conspiracy. Lyteria Hollis, McCarroll's girlfriend? Well, she facilitated cash app payments to shooters and hid the murder weapon from Bank Nightlife at McCarroll's discretion. Reginald Fluker, the bank nightlife shooter? He eventually cooperated with authorities and pleaded guilty. [28:53] The charges were severe, murder for hire conspiracy, using firearms in crimes of violence, interstate murder for hire, obstruction of justice, multiple weapons charges including illegal possession of machine guns, Under federal sentencing guidelines, several charges carried mandatory life sentences. And there's no parole in the federal system. Life means life. Some defendants made strategic decisions. Reginald Fluker signed a cooperation agreement, agreed to testify against McCarroll and others in exchange for a reduced sentence. Carmelo Dirks also cooperated. on April 18th, 2024. He pleaded guilty to transporting a stolen vehicle across state lines. But three defendants, John McCarroll, Darius Rouser, and Lyteria Hollis, refused plea deals. They wanted to go to trial. And the prosecution had a simple strategy. Let the defendants convict themselves. [30:09] October 2024, United States District Court, Southern District of Alabama, Mobile Division. [30:24] The courtroom was packed. Victims' families, media, legal observers. One of the most unusual federal trials Mobile had seen in years. Prosecutors played the Instagram voice messages. The jury heard defendants' own voices discussing the shootings and bragging about attempts and planning future attacks. They showed the Facebook posts, the defendants mocking failed attempts, making jokes about missing the target. They played the jail phone calls. After his arrest, McCarroll on recorded lines from Mobile County Metro Jail, directing Hollis to hide the murder weapon, trying to get Fluker to sign a false affidavit. Witnesses described the chaos at Bank Nightlife, the panic at Paparazzi Lounge, Iman Drummond's frantic 911 call from the Mississippi murder, desperately trying to explain what she had just heard over the phone. Surveillance video from the Scarlet Pearl Casino was shown. Rouser exiting the passenger seat around 1 a.m., approaching the charger with a gun. [31:43] Victim impact was powerful. Medical professionals testified about the paralyzed woman's injuries, about Derek Shaver's fatal wounds, about the six other shooting victims. Reginald Fluker took the stand. He'd signed a cooperation agreement, and he testified that McCarroll handed him the gun at Bank Nightlife, that McCarroll pointed out the target, and that McCarroll directed the shooting. Under cross-examination, Fluker admitted some inconsistencies. He said he didn't know McCarroll until weeks before the shooting, and the payment was unclear. His plea agreement mentioned $20,000, but actual cash app transfers totaled only about $89. Defense attorney Josh Briskman pressed, that would be a quite low amount to kill somebody, right? [32:45] But the core testimony stood. The defense argued these were isolated criminal acts, not a coordinated conspiracy. They suggested random acts of violence better suited for state prosecution. But the evidence was just overwhelming. The Instagram messages were in the conspirators' voices. The jail calls were recorded and timestamped. shell casings from paparazzi matched a gun found at Rouser's friend's apartment. The pattern was kind of undeniable. Prosecutors characterized the case as a street war and a blood feud and asked jurors to hold defendants accountable for death and violence that created a bloody trail of collateral damage across Alabama and Mississippi. The jury deliberated. October 25, 2024. The courtroom was packed and silent. John Fitzgerald McCarroll Jr., guilty. All counts. Darius Rouser, guilty. All counts. by Terry O'Hallis, guilty on all counts except witness tampering. [34:13] Three guilty verdicts, mandatory life sentences ahead. But before they could be imposed, the court wanted to hear from the people who paid the price for this conspiracy. [34:57] It's now April 2nd, 2025, five months after the guilty verdicts. United States District Court Sentencing Day. The courtroom was even more packed than during trial. Victims' families filled the gallery, some wearing memorial buttons with photos of Derek Shavers and Nick Craig. Before the judge imposed sentences, there was something the court wanted to hear. Victim Impact Statements, Derek Shaver's family spoke. His mother described her son. The hardworking man who was kind to everyone. The Walmart team lead who took pride in his work. and the man who was just out enjoying music when someone else's vendetta found him. She addressed the defendants directly and told them her grandson would grow up without a father, that Derek's last weeks were terror and pain, and that their family would never be whole again. [36:13] Nicholas Craig's family spoke next. His mother, Sumoris Tucker, described her son, the Best Buy manager, with creative passions, the man who came home to celebrate his birthday. She described how Nick never made it to Mobile. He was shot in the casino parking lot the day after his 36th birthday. The paralyzed woman's family testified her testimony described life before November 26th, dancing and walking in independence. And after? Wheelchairs, medical equipment, and permanent care needs. A future completely changed. The judge noted her remarkable resilience in facing a lifetime of challenges she never chose. [37:06] When victim statements concluded, U.S. District Judge Terry Moore addressed the defendant. His tone was measured, but firm. He noted the conspiracy's scope, the months of planning, the multiple attempts, the nine victims, the interstate crimes, the use of illegal weapons, and critically, the defendant's own documentation of their crimes. The sentence? McCarroll, age 31, life in prison without possibility of parole. Rouser, age 21, life in prison without possibility of parole. Hollis, age 31, life in prison without possibility of parole. Total restitution ordered $1.2 million for medical expenses, funeral costs, and ongoing care and needs. Although, they're probably not going to see a penny of that. Carmelo Dirks received 84 months for his cooperation. Reginald Fluker, the bank nightlife shooter who cooperated extensively, received 30 years. [38:26] There was no dramatic courtroom reaction, no outburst, just quiet. The kind of quiet that comes when something permanent settles in. Three people, McCarroll, Rouser, and Hollis, would spend the rest of their lives in federal prison. The rest of their lives? In the federal system, life means natural life. No parole, no early release. They will die in custody. [38:59] Today, John McCarroll is serving life without parole at a federal penitentiary. He's 31 years old, could live another 50 years, all of them in prison. Darius Rouser is 21. He was 19 when he killed Nicholas Craig. 20 when he paralyzed a woman at the paparazzi lounge. Life without parole, he'll likely spend the next 60 years in federal custody. And Hollis, 31, life without parole, decades ahead in federal women's prison for facilitating payments and hiding evidence. Was it worth it? The paralyzed woman from the paparazzi lounge continues extensive physical therapy. She's learned to navigate her new reality, but it's still a reality she never chose. And Derek Shaver's six-year-old son is now nine. Growing up without his father, his family said, his whole world revolved around his dad. [40:02] Nick Craig's family continues grieving. His mother described him as, tall, handsome, and respectable, a good son who came home to celebrate his birthday. He was supposed to arrive that September 21st. He never made it. Now, appeals are pending in the 11th Circuit, but given the evidence, the defendants' own Instagram messages, Facebook posts, and recorded jail calls, legal experts say reversal is probably unlikely. The case is closed, the sentences are imposed, but the consequences, they continue. [40:47] So here's what happened. Milton Carter survived unharmed, zero injuries, a perfect failure rate targeting him, a perfect success rate hitting everyone else. McCarroll serving life, Rouser serving life, Hollis serving life, and they'll spend the next five decades or more in federal prison. Seems senseless, doesn't it? Derek Shavers and Nicholas Craig are dead. One woman is paralyzed. Six others carry physical and psychological scars, and it was all based on a false assumption from the very beginning. By the way, if you want full case files, court documents, and behind-the-scenes analysis I used for this episode, if you're subscribed to the email list at truecrimeunheard.com, when you get the notification email for this episode, there will be a secret link in that email where you can download all of this stuff and look at it for yourself. [41:58] Here's what troubles me most about this case, and about so many cases I've investigated over 30 years. How many crimes start with someone being absolutely certain about something that just isn't true? McCarroll was certain Milton Carter orchestrated Ryan Campbell's death. Police said otherwise. The courts convicted someone else. But McCarroll's certainty overrode evidence, investigation, and justice. Every day people act on assumptions they never verify. Every day someone is absolutely certain about something that's just wrong. And every day those bad assumptions combined with access to weapons and a willingness to use violence destroy lives. The target was wrong The premise was wrong The certainty was wrong But the guns were real The bullets were real The deaths were real, John McCarroll pointed to Milton Carter in the nightclub And said, that one Kill him Fifteen months later Two dead, one paralyzed, six wounded Three people serving life sentences And the intended target Walked away unharmed. [43:26] Sometimes the worst crimes aren't about evil. They're about certainty. Being so sure you're right that you may never stop to ask, Hmm, what if I'm wrong? By the time McCarroll asked that question, if he ever did, nine people had already paid the price. I'm Steve Rode, And this has been True Crime Cases You Haven't Heard. If you have information about overlooked true crime cases, you can reach me through the website at truecrimeunheard.com. You can find True Crime Cases You Haven't Heard on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and wherever you listen. Be sure to subscribe so you never miss an episode. And be sure to visit truecrimeunheard.com and sign up for the notification emails so you not only get access to the secret court documents, but also my weekly updates. Until next time, stay curious, stay safe, and stay subscribed. Bye.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is John Fitzgerald McCarroll Jr.?

John Fitzgerald McCarroll Jr. is a 31-year-old Mobile, Alabama resident who orchestrated a murder-for-hire conspiracy between September and December 2022. He hired multiple shooters and provided illegal weapons in an attempt to kill Milton Carter as revenge for a prior killing, but the intended target was never harmed while nine innocent people were shot.

What was the motive behind the murder-for-hire conspiracy?

McCarroll blamed Milton Carter for the October 19, 2020 death of Ryan Campbell, who was described as being like a little brother to McCarroll. However, Mobile Police arrested and convicted a different man, Barron Morris, for Campbell's murder in August 2023. Despite this, McCarroll pursued his revenge campaign against Carter anyway.

Who was Derrick Shavers?

Derrick Shavers was a 31-year-old Mobile resident who worked as a Walmart team lead for five years and was the single father of a six-year-old son. He was shot by Reginald Fluker at Bank Nightlife club on September 18, 2022, in a case of mistaken identity. After fighting for his life for three weeks, Shavers died from his injuries on October 8, 2022.

Who was Nicholaus Craig?

Nicholaus Craig was a 36-year-old Best Buy manager from California who was originally from Mobile, Alabama. He was shot and killed by Darrius Rowser on September 21, 2022, during an attempted carjacking in the Scarlet Pearl Casino parking lot in D'Iberville, Mississippi. Craig had flown to the Gulf Coast to celebrate his birthday and was heading to visit his mother in Mobile when he was killed.

What happened at Paparazzi Lounge in November 2022?

On November 26, 2022, Darrius Rowser opened fire with an illegally modified machinegun inside Paparazzi Lounge in Mobile during a high school reunion afterparty. He shot four innocent people, including a 27-year-old woman who was shot in the neck and left permanently paralyzed. Milton Carter, the intended target, was unharmed.

What role did Instagram play in the investigation?

Darrius Rowser created Instagram voice messages bragging to co-conspirators about the Paparazzi Lounge shooting. Prosecutors described his social media content as being replete with significant evidence. These self-incriminating messages became key evidence at trial, essentially creating a digital confession that helped convict him.

What was the Walmart shooting incident?

On December 27, 2022, Rowser, Jimaurice Pierce, and Karmelo Derks traveled to a Walmart on I-65 Service Road South in Mobile to purchase GPS trackers to locate Milton Carter. During the trip, Rowser and Pierce fired illegally modified machineguns into the self-checkout area, wounding two shoppers.

How did McCarroll attempt to obstruct justice after his arrest?

After his arrest, McCarroll directed his girlfriend Lyteria Hollis via recorded jail phone calls to hide a murder weapon at her residence. Federal agents later seized the gun from her house. McCarroll also attempted to tamper with witness testimony by having Reginald Fluker sign a false affidavit claiming McCarroll was not involved in the conspiracy.

What were the sentences for the main defendants?

On April 2, 2025, U.S. District Judge Terry F. Moorer sentenced John McCarroll, Darrius Rowser, and Lyteria Hollis each to mandatory life in federal prison. Reginald Fluker received 30 years after pleading guilty and cooperating. Karmelo Derks received 84 months for interstate transportation of a stolen vehicle.

What was the total victim count in this conspiracy?

The murder-for-hire conspiracy resulted in two people murdered (Derrick Shavers and Nicholaus Craig), one woman permanently paralyzed from the Paparazzi Lounge shooting, and six additional people wounded across the various incidents. The intended target, Milton Carter, was never harmed despite multiple attempts on his life.

What additional crime was Lyteria Hollis convicted of?

In addition to her murder-for-hire conspiracy and evidence tampering convictions, Lyteria Hollis separately pleaded guilty to wire fraud for obtaining nearly $20,000 in fraudulent Paycheck Protection Program loan proceeds. She lied to the Small Business Administration about operating a nonexistent hair-styling business during the COVID-19 pandemic.

How much restitution was ordered in this case?

Judge Moorer ordered McCarroll, Rowser, and Hollis to pay $1,243,397.72 in restitution to the victims of the murder-for-hire scheme. Additionally, Hollis was ordered to pay $19,985.00 to the SBA for her PPP fraud, and Rowser and Derks were ordered to pay $5,361.00 to the owner of the stolen vehicle.

Which agencies investigated the McCarroll case?

The case was investigated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, the Mobile Police Department, and the D'Iberville, Mississippi Police Department. Assistant U.S. Attorneys Justin Roller, Gaillard Ladd, and Kasee Heisterhagen prosecuted the case.

What happened to Milton Carter, the intended target?

Milton Carter, the man McCarroll blamed for Ryan Campbell's death and targeted for murder, survived every attempt on his life without injury. Despite multiple nightclub shootings and months of conspiracy against him, Carter was never harmed while nine innocent bystanders paid the price for McCarroll's revenge plot.

Are there any pending legal matters related to this case?

Jimaurice Pierce, who pleaded guilty to the murder-for-hire conspiracy, faces a mandatory life sentence and will be sentenced at a later date. Karmelo Derks faces pending accessory to murder charges in Harrison County, Mississippi, for which he is presumed innocent until proven guilty. Appeals from the convicted defendants are pending in the Eleventh Circuit.

Case Timeline

Chronological sequence of key events

October 19, 2020

Ryan Campbell murdered in Mobile

Ryan Campbell, described as being like a little brother to John McCarroll, was killed in Mobile, Alabama. This death would become the catalyst for McCarroll's revenge conspiracy against Milton Carter.

December 1, 2020

Barron Morris arrested for Campbell murder

Mobile Police arrested Barron Morris for the murder of Ryan Campbell. Despite this arrest, McCarroll would later blame Milton Carter for Campbell's death and pursue a revenge campaign against him.

September 18, 2022

Bank Nightlife shooting kills Derrick Shavers

At approximately 2:30 a.m., Reginald Fluker opened fire at Bank Nightlife club at 271 Azalea Road in Mobile using a gun provided by McCarroll. Fluker shot the wrong person, hitting 31-year-old Derrick Shavers four times in a case of mistaken identity. Milton Carter was unharmed.

September 21, 2022

Nicholaus Craig murdered in Mississippi carjacking

At approximately 2:00 a.m., Darrius Rowser shot and killed Nicholaus Craig, 36, during an attempted carjacking at the Scarlet Pearl Casino Resort parking lot in D'Iberville, Mississippi. Craig had just celebrated his 36th birthday and was heading to Mobile to visit his mother.

September 21, 2022

Stolen vehicle burned to destroy evidence

After the Mississippi murder, Rowser and Karmelo Derks traveled back to Mobile and burned the stolen Nissan Altima they had been using at Azalea Apartments to destroy evidence linking them to the crime.

October 8, 2022

Derrick Shavers dies from injuries

After fighting for his life for approximately three weeks at USA Hospital, Derrick Shavers died from the gunshot wounds he sustained at Bank Nightlife. He left behind a six-year-old son whose whole world revolved around his father.

October 13, 2022

Candlelight vigil held for Derrick Shavers

Family and friends gathered for a candlelight vigil to honor Derrick Shavers, spelling out Long Live Day on the concrete. His sister Siera Gray described him as a hard-working man who was very kind to people and did not meet any strangers.

November 26, 2022

Paparazzi Lounge mass shooting paralyzes victim

At approximately 2:16 a.m., Darrius Rowser opened fire with an illegally modified machinegun at Paparazzi Lounge during a high school reunion afterparty. He shot four innocent bystanders, including a 27-year-old woman who was shot in the neck and permanently paralyzed. Milton Carter was again unharmed.

November 27, 2022

Rowser brags about shooting on Instagram

After the Paparazzi Lounge shooting, Darrius Rowser created Instagram voice messages bragging to co-conspirators about the attack. These self-incriminating recordings would later become key evidence at trial.

December 27, 2022

Walmart shooting wounds two shoppers

At 8:35 p.m., Rowser, Jimaurice Pierce, and Karmelo Derks traveled to the Walmart on I-65 Service Road South in Mobile to purchase GPS trackers to locate Milton Carter. Rowser and Pierce fired illegally modified machineguns into the self-checkout area, striking two shoppers.

December 30, 2022

Karmelo Derks arrested for Walmart shooting

Karmelo Derks, 18 years old, was arrested and transported to Mobile County Metro Jail following the Walmart shooting incident three days earlier.

January 20, 2023

Detective testimony reveals evidence linking shootings

A Mobile police detective laid out a largely circumstantial case in court linking suspects to three Mobile shootings, publicly revealing the evidence connecting the Bank Nightlife, Paparazzi Lounge, and Walmart incidents.

March 16, 2023

Murder-for-hire plot publicly revealed

Mobile detective publicly revealed that the Bank Nightlife victim Derrick Shavers was killed in a mistaken identity murder-for-hire plot, marking the first time the conspiracy theory was made public.

August 14, 2023

Barron Morris pleads guilty to Campbell murder

Barron Morris pleaded guilty to intentionally murdering Ryan Campbell and was sentenced to 20 years in Alabama State Penitentiary. This confirmed that Milton Carter had nothing to do with Campbell's death, yet McCarroll had already killed innocent people pursuing revenge against Carter.

August 24, 2023

Federal indictment filed against conspiracy members

A federal grand jury returned a sealed indictment in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Alabama, Case No. 1:23-CR-00169, charging McCarroll, Rowser, Hollis, Fluker, Pierce, and Derks with multiple counts including murder-for-hire conspiracy.

September 27, 2023

John McCarroll arrested by FBI

FBI agents arrested John Fitzgerald McCarroll Jr. in Mobile, Alabama. He was charged with conspiracy to commit murder for hire, murder for hire, and tampering with a witness.

October 1, 2023

McCarroll directs obstruction from jail

After his arrest, McCarroll directed his girlfriend Lyteria Hollis via recorded jail phone calls to hide a murder weapon at her residence. He also arranged for Reginald Fluker to sign a false affidavit claiming McCarroll was not involved in the conspiracy.

November 1, 2023

Federal agents seize hidden murder weapon

Federal agents executed a search warrant at Lyteria Hollis's residence and seized the murder weapon that McCarroll had directed her to hide. During the investigation, agents also discovered evidence of Hollis's PPP fraud involving a fictitious hair salon.

April 18, 2024

Karmelo Derks pleads guilty to federal charges

Karmelo Derks, 19, entered a guilty plea in federal court to transporting a stolen vehicle across state lines. As part of the plea agreement, prosecutors agreed to request dismissal of the carjacking charge.

May 22, 2024

Superseding indictment filed

A federal grand jury returned a superseding indictment with refined charges against McCarroll, Rowser, Pierce, and Hollis, including updated counts and forfeiture allegations.

September 30, 2024

Jury selection begins for federal trial

Jury selection commenced in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Alabama before Judge Terry F. Moorer for the three-week federal murder-for-hire trial of McCarroll, Rowser, and Hollis.

October 7, 2024

Federal trial begins with opening statements

The three-week federal jury trial began with opening statements. Prosecutors characterized the case as a relentless campaign of revenge that created a bloody trail of collateral damage across Alabama and Mississippi.

October 22, 2024

Reginald Fluker testifies against co-defendants

Cooperating witness Reginald Fluker testified that McCarroll handed him a gun at Bank Nightlife and pointed out the target. Under cross-examination, defense attorneys highlighted inconsistencies regarding payment amounts and the timeline of events.

October 25, 2024

Guilty verdicts returned on all counts

The jury returned guilty verdicts against all three defendants. John McCarroll, Darrius Rowser, and Lyteria Hollis were each convicted on all counts related to the murder-for-hire conspiracy.

December 6, 2024

Reginald Fluker sentenced to 30 years

U.S. District Judge Terry F. Moorer sentenced Reginald Fluker to 30 years in federal prison for his role as the Bank Nightlife shooter. His sentence was reduced from mandatory life due to his substantial cooperation with prosecutors.

April 2, 2025

Victim impact statements delivered at sentencing

Several victims of the murder-for-hire conspiracy addressed the court to provide impact statements. Judge Terry F. Moorer noted the importance of the victims' statements and the resilience they demonstrated, particularly the paralyzed victim.

April 2, 2025

Life sentences imposed on three defendants

Judge Terry F. Moorer sentenced John McCarroll, Darrius Rowser, and Lyteria Hollis each to mandatory life in federal prison. The court ordered them to pay $1,243,397.72 in joint restitution to victims. Karmelo Derks received 84 months.

April 11, 2025

McCarroll files notice of appeal

John McCarroll filed a notice of appeal with the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals challenging his conviction and life sentence. Appeals from the other convicted defendants are also pending.

Primary Sources & Citations

All information verified against official court records and primary documentation

100% Verified Sources

Every fact cited in this investigation is sourced from official court documents, FBI records, or verified news archives. No speculation or unverified claims.

Primary Court Documents

  • Federal and State Court Records Official case filings and exhibits
  • FBI Affidavits and Reports Law enforcement documentation

Verified News Sources

  • News Archives Cross-referenced with official documents

For Researchers: All court documents available to email subscribers. Citations follow Bluebook legal citation format where applicable.

author avatar
Steve Rhode Podcaster - Investigator
30-year investigative journalist, former police dispatcher, and SAR pilot. Host of True Crime Cases You Haven't Heard podcast.